According to Dr. Donald Clifton’s book How Full Is Your Bucket, the number one reason people leave their jobs is that they don't feel appreciated.
According to research from Gallup, employees that receive regular recognition and praise:
- Increase their own productivity
- Increase engagement among their coworkers
- Are more likely to stay with the organization longer
- Receive higher loyalty and satisfaction scores from customers
But rewarding employees doesn’t have to cost money. Here are 20 ways to reward employees without spending any money.
There is a lot of debate around whether money should be used to reward employees.
Does money really motivate employees?
As I’ve discussed many times, the short answer is no. Of course, everyone wants money and everyone needs money to live, but using money as a motivator isn’t a good idea. Reward employees by tapping into their passions.
Unless you’re extremely careful with how you use rewards, you get people who are just working for the money… We need to compensate people fairly, but when we try to use money to motivate them to do tasks, it can very likely backfire on us.Edward Deci
One of the most famous experiments on this is by Dr. Edward Deci, looking at whether emotional feedback or money would increase engagement with work.
People were sitting in a room and tried to solve a puzzle while Deci measured how much time they put in, before giving up. For Group A, he offered a cash reward for successfully solving the puzzle, and as you might expect, those people spent almost twice as much time trying to solve the puzzle as those people in Group B who weren’t offered a prize.
A surprising thing happened the next day, when Deci told Group A that there wasn’t enough money to pay them this time around: Group A lost interest in the puzzle.
Group B, on the other hand, having never been offered money in exchange for working on the puzzles, worked on the puzzles longer and longer in each consecutive session and maintained a higher level of sustained interest than Group A.
Deci’s experiment showed that money actually decreased intrinsic motivation because such external rewards thwart our “three psychological needs — to feel autonomous, to feel competent and to feel related to others.”
How money affects intrinsic motivation
In a meta-analysis by Edward Deci and colleagues, they looked at how money affects intrinsic motivation. Their results showed that there is a consistent negative effect of using incentives on intrinsic motivation. These effects were particularly strong when the tasks were interesting or enjoyable rather than boring or meaningless.
What they found was that for every standard deviation increase in reward, intrinsic motivation for interesting tasks decreases by about 25%. When rewards are tangible and foreseeable (if subjects know in advance how much extra money they will receive) intrinsic motivation decreases by 36%.
Intrinsic motivation has also been proven to be a stronger predictor of job performance than extrinsic motivation, so what that means is that money not only lowers motivation, but also job performance.
The more people focus on their salaries, the less they will focus on satisfying their intellectual curiosity, learning new skills, or having fun, and those are the things that engage employees the most.
How emotions affect employee motivation
The larger the monetary reward, the poorer the performance. – money doesn't motivate us, at all, instead emotions do.Dan Pink
This is where it starts to get very interesting.
According to the research that Dan Pink talks about, it’s our emotions that actually motivate us. First, let’s discuss why that is, and then we can discuss how as leaders, we can tap into those emotions.
The parts of the brain that deal with emotions are actually connected to those that deal with cognition (things like memory and attention). Our emotional processes directly affect our motivation to work. Emotions are actually the main influencer of our performance.
What’s also interesting is that negative emotions like fear and sadness can lead to brain activity and thought patterns that are detrimental to creative, productive work. Things like avoiding risk, narrowing your mind, and being unable to make a decision are all affected by negative emotions.
One of my favorite examples of all of this is Barbara Fredrickson’s Broaden and Build theory, which states that positive emotions (like joy and happiness) broaden our scope of thinking and creativity, and allows us to build new skills. Negative emotions do the opposite.
Neuroscientist Antonio Damasio found that when people lose the ability to experience emotions, they cannot make up their mind.
Knowing this, it’s important that we work on developing those positive emotions and try our best to get feelings like joy and happiness as much as possible.
Exercising will automatically release mood-enhancing chemicals and endorphins into your body. This can immediately lift your mood and lower stress. Increasing our physical health boosts our emotional health.
Meditation is by far my favorite thing to increase positive emotions. Meditation has been shown to literally rewire your brain, and makes you be more mindful, lowers your stress, and makes you happier. Recent research by Barbara Fredrickson and her colleagues has revealed that people who meditate daily display more positive emotions that those who do not.
3. Gratitude journal
In a study published in the Journal of Research in Personality, researchers examined a group of 90 undergraduate students who were split into two groups. The first group wrote about a positive experience each day for three consecutive days. The second group wrote about a control topic.
Three months later, the students who wrote about positive experiences had better mood levels, fewer visits to the health center, and experienced fewer illnesses, after only writing for three days!
How do you reward employees?
Let us know your thoughts on Twitter @Officevibe.
Equip HR and managers with tools to engage, recognize, and drive performance.